Key takeaways
- Taking two turns immediately (Rule 44.1) is usually the fastest way to resolve an error without ruining your score.
- A valid protest requires an immediate hail of 'Protest' and, for larger boats, a red flag.
- Arbitration offers a 20-30% scoring penalty as an alternative to a full disqualification (DSQ).
- Rule 14 requires all boats to avoid contact, regardless of who has the right of way.
- Always notify the Race Committee at the finish line if you intend to file a formal protest.
The Instant Fix: Taking Your Circles
We have all been there. You are approaching the windward mark on a tight starboard layline on Lake Mendota, and a port-tack boat tries to squeeze in. There is a yell, a frantic bear-away, and suddenly everyone is shouting. In the heat of a regatta, an infringement of the Racing Rules of Sailing (RRS) happens in a split second.
Your first and most efficient tool for resolution is Rule 44.1. If you break a rule in Part 2 (When Boats Meet) while racing, you can take a penalty immediately. For most fleet racing, this is the 'Two-Turns Penalty.' By doing two tacks and two gybes in the same direction as soon as you are clear of other boats, you exonerate yourself. In many modern regattas, specifically those using the V1 appendix or specific sailing instructions, this might even be reduced to a 'One-Turn Penalty' for incidents outside the zone.
Taking your turns on the water is almost always faster than spending two hours in a humid yacht club basement defending your position to a protest committee. It preserves the sportsmanship of the fleet and allows you to focus on the next leg rather than stewing over a mistake.
The Protest: When Circles Aren't Enough
Sometimes, the situation isn't clear-cut. Maybe you don't believe you broke a rule, or perhaps the other boat caused serious damage. This is where Rule 60 and 61 come into play.
To validly protest another boat, you must follow a very specific set of steps. First, you must hail 'Protest' immediately. On a boat over 6 meters, you must also display a red flag (usually from the backstay) until you finish. I’ve seen many sailors lose a clear-cut case in the protest room simply because they waited thirty seconds to grab their flag or forgot to shout the word 'Protest' loud enough for the other boat to hear.
Once you cross the finish line, you must notify the race committee of your intent to protest. Then, the clock starts on your protest time limit—usually 60 to 90 minutes after the last boat finishes.
On-Water Arbitration: The Middle Ground
In many Wisconsin regattas, like the bigger events on Lake Michigan or the inland scow championships, organizers use 'Arbitration.' This is a fantastic bridge between taking turns and a full-blown hearing.
In arbitration, one judge meets with both parties for about 15 minutes. There are no witnesses. The judge listens to both sides and gives an opinion. If the judge thinks you broke a rule, they might offer a 'Post-Race Penalty'—usually 20% or 30% of the fleet size added to your score. This is worse than taking your turns on the water, but significantly better than a Disqualification (DSQ). If you accept the penalty, the matter is dropped. If you don't, it goes to a formal hearing.
A Real-World Example from the Great Lakes
I remember a blustery fall race out of Milwaukee where two J/105s tangled at the leeward gate. Boat A claimed Boat B didn't give them mark-room under Rule 18.2. Boat B claimed they were already clear ahead when they reached the zone. Boat B didn't take circles because they were certain they were right.
In the protest room, Boat A had a clear GoPro video (yes, these are allowed now) showing they had an overlap. Because Boat B chose not to take a penalty on the water or accept an arbitration penalty, they were hit with a DSQ. That's a 0-point score for the race in a 20-boat fleet. Had they taken their turns or even the arbitration penalty, they would have likely finished in the top half of the fleet.
Safety and Ethics
Never forget Rule 14: the requirement to avoid contact. Even if you have the right of way, you must do everything you can to avoid a collision. If you have the right of way but fail to avoid contact that results in damage, you can be penalized as well.
Sailing is a self-policing sport. There are no referees on every corner of the course. When you know you’ve fouled someone, the most 'Wisconsin' thing you can do is tip your hat, sail clear, and do your turns. It builds respect among your competitors and keeps the focus where it should be: on the wind, the waves, and the thrill of the race.
Written by Dmitry Shteyn — Wisconsin sailor and educator. Find more sailing notes on the daily blog or read the longer guides.
